Skip to content

Best quarterback prop bets for the 2019 NFL season

Icon Sportswire / Getty

This week, we're starting a three-part series covering prop bets revolving around offensive players for the 2019 NFL season. Up first are the quarterbacks, and no one's led the league in both passing yards and touchdowns since Peyton Manning did it in 2013.

Odds to lead NFL in passing yards

Player Odds
Matt Ryan 9-2
Patrick Mahomes 9-2
Andrew Luck 6-1
Aaron Rodgers 7-1
Ben Roethlisberger 7-1
Baker Mayfield 10-1
Jameis Winston 15-1
Drew Brees 16-1
Carson Wentz 20-1
Philip Rivers 20-1
Jared Goff 25-1
Tom Brady 25-1
Derek Carr 40-1
Jimmy Garoppolo 40-1
Kirk Cousins 40-1
Kyler Murray 40-1
Matthew Stafford 40-1
Deshaun Watson 50-1
Cam Newton 75-1
Russell Wilson 75-1
Sam Darnold 75-1
Dak Prescott 100-1
Ryan Fitzpatrick 100-1
Daniel Jones 125-1
Joe Flacco 125-1
Nick Foles 125-1
Andy Dalton 150-1
Case Keenum 150-1
Dwayne Haskins 150-1
Josh Allen 150-1
Mitchell Trubisky 150-1
Marcus Mariota 150-1
Eli Manning 200-1
Lamar Jackson 200-1

The passing-yards leaderboard has been pretty consistent over the years. Since 2011, just four players have topped it: Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger, Tom Brady, and Peyton Manning.

You can make a case against all three of the active quarterbacks in 2019. While Brees is becoming more efficient as a passer, his yardage dropped significantly in each of the last two seasons. The Saints went from calling pass plays 63.4 percent of the time in 2016 to 56.3 in 2017, then all the way down to 54.3 percent last season. Brady's in the same boat, as New England's passing-play percentage sunk from 59.7 in 2017 to 54.9 last season. Roethlisberger is in the best situation of the three to keep the trend going, though his numbers will likely take a massive hit after the loss of Antonio Brown.

Here's who we think could rack up the most passing yards in 2019.

Favorite - Matt Ryan (9-2)

Ryan's had 4,500 yards or more in five of the last six seasons with the Falcons. Had it not been for a clunker in '17, he could have edged out Brady, whose light 4,577 yards led the pack.

This is an optimal time to buy on Ryan, who finally gets a change at offensive coordinator following a shoddy two seasons with Steve Sarkisian. Dirk Koetter steps in for his second stint, having held the role from 2012-14. In those three years under Koetter, Ryan attempted the most passes in his career. Toss in a favorable supporting cast and the veteran could earn top spot in this department for the first time.

Underdog - Baker Mayfield (10-1)

There's a lot to like about Mayfield following his first cup of coffee in the NFL. After swapping out Hue Jackson for Freddie Kitchens, Mayfield averaged 8.6 yards per attempt in his rookie season. Don't be surprised if the Browns chuck it a ton with a group of pass-catchers that includes Odell Beckham Jr., Jarvis Landry, Antonio Callaway, Nick Chubb, and David Njoku.

Long shot - Kyler Murray (50-1)

We wouldn't mind taking a flier on this one. Murray's a wild card, coming into the NFL as an undersized quarterback on a bad team with a first-year head coach. The Cardinals are rebuilding, but unlike most of the other bottom-feeders, could at least be fun to watch. The franchise spruced up Murray's receiving corps in the draft to make life a little easier in Year 1. Given how often they'll be trailing, expect the Cardinals to throw a lot.

Odds to lead NFL in passing touchdowns

Player Odds
Andrew Luck 5-1
Patrick Mahomes 5-1
Matt Ryan 7-1
Aaron Rodgers 9-1
Baker Mayfield 10-1
Jameis Winston 14-1
Ben Roethlisberger 18-1
Philip Rivers 18-1
Carson Wentz 20-1
Drew Brees 20-1
Tom Brady 20-1
Kirk Cousins 25-1
Deshaun Watson 25-1
Russell Wilson 30-1
Jared Goff 35-1
Jimmy Garoppolo 35-1
Sam Darnold 35-1
Kyler Murray 40-1
Matthew Stafford 40-1
Cam Newton 50-1
Dak Prescott 50-1
Derek Carr 50-1
Andy Dalton 75-1
Mitchell Trubisky 75-1
Nick Foles 75-1
Joe Flacco 100-1
Josh Allen 100-1
Lamar Jackson 100-1
Case Keenum 150-1
Dwayne Haskins 150-1
Daniel Jones 150-1
Eli Manning 150-1
Marcus Mariota 150-1
Ryan Fitzpatrick 150-1
Drew Lock 150-1
Josh Rosen 150-1

Seven different quarterbacks have led the league in passing touchdowns since 2012. Here's who we like this season.

Favorite - Patrick Mahomes (5-1)

Mahomes should regress from his 50-touchdown mark. However, that's no reason to avoid him altogether.

It'd be lazy to claim that defenses will figure out Mahomes in his second full year under center. He was as close to a cheat code we've seen, from his pure arm strength to his no-look passes. If coming back down to earth means 40-plus passing scores, we're not getting cute and fading him - the Chiefs quarterback is the guy.

Underdog - Carson Wentz (20-1)

This is all about what's around Wentz. The Eagles acquired a vertical threat in DeSean Jackson and drafted the best red-zone target in the class, J.J. Arcega-Whiteside. Add in mainstay Zach Ertz and Wentz has no shortage of weapons.

Long shot - Mitchell Trubisky (75-1)

The jury still appears to be out on Trubisky, another wild card who could take a huge step forward in Year 3 or flop completely. The Bears' offense improved last season under first-year head coach Matt Nagy, who, thanks to general manager Ryan Pace, had touchdown threats to work with following a splashy 2018 free-agency period. If there's another leap in the cards for 2019, Trubisky's ceiling is high.

Alex Kolodziej is theScore's betting writer. He's a graduate of Eastern Illinois who has been involved in the sports betting industry for 11 years. He can quote every line from "Rounders" and appreciates franchises that regularly wear alternate jerseys. Find him on Twitter @AlexKoIodziej.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox