CFB Blitz: Big Ten's rough day among Week 12 takeaways

Getty

The weekly CFB Blitz is the spot to catch up on the most important developments from the day's action and examine their significance moving forward.

Rough day for Big Ten's best

It was a brutal day for the top of the Big Ten with UCLA and Indiana joining Ohio State in taking road losses to unranked teams. That certainly won't help the conference - already on thin ice to get three teams in the playoff field - garner some respect from the CFP committee.

UCLA

The end of the undefeated run is tough for the Bruins, but the injury to Ty Dieffenbach is probably Bob Chesney's bigger concern. Dieffenbach has been vital to the offense since taking over once Nico Iamaleava was lost for the season. However, after being carted off in overtime versus Michigan, the offense might be down to third-string Madden Iamaleava. He's seen limited action when Diffenbach was sidelined, and it's probably safe to say the Bruins are cooked if he's the starter.

If Dieffenbach's injury is serious and UCLA were to fall to USC next weekend to finish the season 10-2, the committee could decide to leave the Bruins out of the playoff. Chesney might just have to resort to a jump-pass-only offense after flashing that in the biggest moment versus Michigan.

Indiana

After going 25 games undefeated from last season's title run to the start of the 2026 campaign, Indiana now has two losses in its last five games. Saturday's setback came in overtime after Paddy McAteer missed a 37-yard field goal that would've forced a second extra session versus Washington. The defeat marked a lot of firsts for Cignetti with the Hoosiers.

Cignetti played musical chairs at quarterback and kicker in an attempt to spark the offense. Josh Hoover replaced Grant Wilson at QB, but both passers missed numerous chances to put explosive plays on the board. McAteer took over for Nico Radicic after a blocked kick, but that ended poorly in OT.

Indiana's been hit hard with injuries - especially on the offensive line - but Cignetti's tinkering clearly shows that he knows his team doesn't have much separation from the rest of the league.

The Hoosiers finish against Purdue, but they now need help to make the Big Ten title game. With a weak nonconference schedule, would the committee leave the defending champions out of the field at 10-2 with only one ranked win?

Finally some joy for Michigan

It wasn't pretty - in fact, it was incredibly ugly for the majority of the contest - but Michigan's win over UCLA was perhaps the most-needed victory in the country for any head coach. Kyle Whittingham's tenure has been a disaster in Ann Arbor, but Saturday offered at least a brief reprieve for the coach in Year 1.

The offense once again looked stuck for the vast majority of the contest, but a couple of plays by Bryce Underwood showed why he was a five-star recruit to begin with. First came a perfectly thrown third-down play to put the Wolverines' only touchdown on the board.

The second was the game-winner - a laser while rolling out to secure the biggest win of Underwood's career at Michigan.

It's hard to say if the win did anything for Whittingham's status moving forward with Michigan. A new athletic director will likely decide his fate, and Underwood's future with the program as well. However, the fan base desperately needed a good Saturday to change the mood in Ann Arbor - and that happened against UCLA.

Next up is the saddest version of "The Game" versus Ohio State in 60 years. The last time both teams had at least four losses entering the rivalry contest was 1966.

Not the same old Nebraska

Charlie Brown never did get to kick the football in the Peanuts comic strip, but the college football version of Charlie Brown has finally beaten a ranked opponent after years of failure. Nebraska's 31-game losing streak to top-25 teams had become one of the longest-running jokes in the sport, and each opportunity to snap it somehow produced a more painful loss. In the Cornhuskers' last chance, just over a month ago, they blew an 11-point lead in the fourth quarter to lose to Indiana.

Consider Saturday's win over Ohio State the start of a new chapter in Lincoln. This isn't the Nebraska we've grown accustomed to that makes mistake after mistake down the stretch to lose in agonizing fashion. The difference: This time, Matt Rhule had the better quarterback.

Rhule signed Anthony Colandrea in the offseason to replace the departed Dylan Raiola. While Colandrea lacked Raiola's recruiting accolades, he's more of the dual threat that Rhule wants at quarterback. That was on display Saturday with Colandrea's 200 yards passing and three touchdowns combined with 63 yards rushing and a score. He thrived on third and fourth down, converting 12-of-18 chances to keep drives alive.

That helped Nebraska hold the ball for over 10 minutes more than Ohio State, a proven recipe for knocking off ranked opponents with plenty of NFL talent on the offensive side of the football.

It won't take long to find out if the ranked-opponent curse has really been broken: Iowa awaits in the season finale. If Colandrea can maintain this level of play, Nebraska is likely to turn the Ohio State victory into a two-game ranked winning streak.

Day failed Ohio State this year

Ben Jackson / Getty Images Sport / Getty

It's going to be a long week, a long month, and a long offseason (provided he's still the coach) for Ryan Day in Columbus. After Ohio State became the first ranked team to lose to Nebraska since 2016, Day is an astonishing 5-6 in his last 11 games versus FBS opponents. While that stretch of games did feature some of the best teams in the country, it's an inexcusable record for the head coach of Ohio State.

It's easy to zero in on Day's timeout usage in the loss to Nebraska: He left the Buckeyes with only one to burn in the final minutes of a three-point game. However, his season-long issue has been the lack of a solid backup plan at quarterback. Julian Sayin's injury essentially ended the team's campaign, as true freshman Luke Fahey clearly isn't capable of consistent quality play at this point in his career.

Ohio State's 28 points may be acceptable, but the game exposed Fahey's inability to deliver in the big moments. Thanks to a three-and-out and an interception in back-to-back drives in the second half, a 21-21 tie turned into a 31-21 lead for Nebraska, effectively ending the game.

Plenty of other teams have lost their starting quarterbacks to injuries but had viable options standing by. UCLA and Oregon fit that mold, with veteran backups now leading both teams to likely playoff berths. Day didn't have a workable plan in the event that Sayin got hurt, and the penalty will be Ohio State's worst season in 15 years.

Nobody starts like Wake Forest

Although college football has no mercy rule, the ACC might want to consider implementing one for Wake Forest games. Jake Dickert's made the Demon Deacons the most prepared team in the country, and they're blowing the doors off their opponents in the opening half on a weekly basis. Saturday's victim was Georgia Tech. The Yellow Jackets became the first team to score on Wake Forest in the first frame since Oct. 10, but they still trailed 36-7 at the break. That puts Dickert and the Demon Deacons in the same class as 2018 Alabama.

The ACC looked like a one-bid league earlier this season with Miami a clear cut above the rest. Any other team from the conference was going to need to do something significant to catch the eye of the CFP committee. Judging by the past five weeks, Wake Forest understood the assignment. It would be borderline malpractice for the committee to leave the Demon Deacons out of the field now, regardless of the outcome of an ACC title matchup against Miami.

BYU limps to the finish line

BYU's defeat of Notre Dame remains one of the best wins of the college football season, and it's the biggest reason the Cougars are still in the CFP field. However, it's becoming clearer every week that the victory was incredibly costly. While BYU avoided a disastrous loss at Kansas on Saturday in triple overtime, the five games following the matchup against the Fighting Irish have mostly been slogs:

  • 39-31 2OT loss to unranked UCF
  • 27-20 home win over unranked Arizona State
  • 28-20 loss at Utah
  • 28-7 home win over unranked Baylor
  • 31-29 3OT win over unranked Kansas

BYU is in an interesting spot heading into the final week of the season. The Cougars need Texas Tech to lose in order for them to make the Big 12 title game. That would give the Cougars a second shot at Utah, and a win would lock in a playoff berth. However, BYU might still be able to get into the field as a 10-2 team without playing for the conference title. Regardless, the committee probably wants to see more than a triple-overtime win versus a 4-7 opponent in order to feel good about including the Cougars.

XRedditFacebookWhatsAppEmailSMS

More Stories